Gifts That Mean More: The Best Personalized Finds for the Holidays

Front row (left to right) Dylan Dreyer, the author Amy E. Goodman, the author’s childhood friend Roberta Maxwell-Long, Al Roker; Back row, Craig Melvin.

The best gifts aren't always the biggest or most expensive ones…they're the ones that make someone feel truly seen. There's something extra special about a gift created with one particular person in mind. From custom keepsakes and personalized home accents to thoughtful treasures they'll enjoy for years to come, these finds go beyond the ordinary to make holiday gifting magical and meaningful.

Here are some of my favorite personalized gift ideas as shared on NBC’s TODAY show to make this holiday season even more memorable!

The Essential Embroidered Slippers, $98 | Brunch

Brunch’s Essential Core slippers in Brown.

Who doesn't love slipping into those plush hotel slippers? Well, now you can have a pair that's made to last! Meet The Essential Slipper from New York-based brand Brunch. It’s where slipper meets sneakeR: They're super-soft, with a terry cloth upper, cushy lining, and a durable, sneaker-inspired sole, so you can wear them inside AND out. And here's the fun part: you can personalize them with a name, initials, or even cute little icons, choosing your font and thread color. They're even machine washable! A little everyday luxury, made uniquely theirs. Available in women’s & men’s sizes

  • Each slipper can accommodate up to 3 icons and/or letters (for a maximum total of 6 icons)

  • 12 icons to choose from: heart, bow, smiley face, star, cherry, cloud, diamond, hotdog, apple, football, basketball, tennis ball

  • 3 font options: block, bubble, script

  • 10 thread colors: red, orange, yellow, green, blue, baby blue, purple, light pink, cream, black

Essential Core (Terry) colors

  • Navy

  • Black

  • Dark Gray

  • Dune

  • Beige

  • Cream

  • Chive (seasonal)

  • Bordeaux (seasonal)

  • Oyster (seasonal)

  • Espresso (seasonal)

XMAS Shipping Deadlines:

Last day to order to receive in time for Christmas with standard shipping: 12/4/2026.

The brand does NOT offer expedited shipping on our embroidery orders.

Personalized Pantry Decor | Things Remembered

Looking for gifts that are both beautiful and useful? These personalized kitchen pieces from Things Remembered add a special touch to everyday entertaining—and are almost too pretty to put in the pantry!

Engraved Cake Dome with Wood Base, $64

This cake dome (base 7.5" H x 11" D)  is perfect for displaying everything from cakes and cookies to cheeses and charcuterie with a base made of Acacia wood.

Things Remembered

Personalized Large Glass Container with Acacia Lid aka Coffee Container, $59 

The Large Glass Container works for beautifully displaying items like coffee beans, granola, nuts, and grains. I love its generous size with a 50 oz capacity.

Things Remembered

Walled Honey Jar, $65

A Walled Honey Jar – with the sweet bee on the lid–comes complete with a honey dipper, and the Ceramic Jar is meant to be for storing cookies, but also perfect for hiding candies and more! 

Things Remembered

Things Remembered

You can personalize these pieces by adding a family name, a favorite saying, or even a special date. Bonus: personalization is included in the price!

XMAS Shipping Deadlines: 

Standard shipping cutoff for Christmas delivery is Tuesday, 12/15/2026

Customers who select Rush shipping can order by 2pm Central Time on Wednesday, 12/23/2026


One-of-a-Kind Painting Sets for People & Pets, $28-40 | Uncommon Goods

Some gifts you unwrap. Others? You create together forever!

Layers of Love Handprints, $40

Here's a gift that places the whole family in one beautiful artwork display! The Layers of Love Handprint Kit lets up to five family members, even your pets, leave their mark!

handprint art in layers, pink and blue handprints on glass, assored pens and plastic roller, also art is displayed upright in a wooden stand.

Uncommon Goods

Each person creates a colorful handprint on an individual plexiglass panel using the provided, washable paint color, and when you layer them together in the wooden display frame? You get this gorgeous, layered family creation. It comes with everything you need to create a keepsake you'll treasure for years!

Gif of 5 plexiglass handprints and a paw print being layered upon one another in a wooden stand.

Uncommon Goods

Pawcasso Ornament Painting Kit for Pets, Set of 4, $28

For the pet parent who has everything, how about a gift made by their fur baby? This is the Pawcasso Ornament Painting Kit from Uncommon Goods, where your pets create the art!

Paw pet print kit from Uncommon Goods

Uncommon Goods

Just place four paw-shaped birchwood ornaments in the included bag, add the nontoxic paints, seal it up, and let your dog or cat go to town with their paws!

Uncommon Goods

Tip: once the ornaments are sealed in the plastic bag, you can put a pet treat atop the bag to encourage thoughtful paw placement! The result? Four, one-of-a-kind ornaments that are made with love by your pet! Isn’t that something? You can choose from two festive color combinations: blue/white or red/green. The kit is made in New Hampshire.

black dog licking treat off of a plastic bag that contains within it paw print ornaments covered in paint.

Uncommon Goods

XMAS Shipping Deadlines:

12/17/2026 is the standard shipping cutoff; expedited is 12/21/2026


Pressed Glass Photo Ornament, $26.25 sale with code “SHAREJOY” | Artifact Uprising  

3 sizes of brass ornaments with green grosgrain ribbon tied in bows

Artifact Uprising

Frame those milestone moments with a timeless, personalized ornament! Available in three elegant shapes (oval, landscape or circle), it features a brass frame with durable glass panes and a double-sided photo, so your favorite memory can be admired from every angle. Artifact Uprising uses archival paper which means that the photograph won’t fade from year to year.

Brass ornament with a personalized photo inside next to a navy box with two grostrain ribbons or red and green atop it.

Artifact Uprising

Choose from evergreen or red grosgrain ribbon, and it even comes in a beautiful blue gift box, ready for gifting. For a little extra, you can also add a 2026 brass year tag to commemorate the moment for years to come!

Up to 25% off sitewide with code SHAREJOY. This special Holiday Shop Sale runs from 11/18-11/24/2026. 


XMAS Shipping Deadlines:

12/15/2026 Standard Shipping; 12/18/26 Rush Shipping


Personalized Game Sets, $35 and up | Mark & Graham

Tabletop and traditional games are having a moment and a revival, and I love how they are bringing people back together. So put your screens away, and take game night up a notch with personalized game sets from Mark & Graham, starting at $35. They're fun, interactive gifts that make every game a little more personal.

Add personalization for $17.

Rummy Tile Game Set, $199 in White, Camel or Navy

Mark & Graham

Leather Playing Cards Set, $35 in Camel or Navy

Navy leather cards set with a gold monogram reading KSM.

Mark & Graham

Best-selling Leather Poker Set, sale from $89  in Black, Racing Green, Pink, Red or Camel

Mark & Graham

Horsebit Leather Domino Set $129 in navy only | Mark & Graham

Mark & Graham

XMAS Shipping Deadlines:

To receive in time for Christmas with standard shipping: December 17, 2026

Expedited shipping: December 21, 2026

This is an editorial segment and article. Prices reflect time of publication.